| Year | Team | Tournament MVP |
| 2012 | Air Force | Jason Torf, G, Air Force |
| 2011 | Air Force | Jacques Lamoureux, F, Air Force |
| 2010 | RIT | Cameron Burt, F, RIT |
| 2009 | Air Force | Matt Fairchild, F, Air Force |
| 2008 | Air Force | Brent Olson, F, Air Force |
| 2007 | Air Force | |
| 2006 | Holy Cross | James Sixsmith, F, Holy Cross |
| 2005 | Mercyhurst | Scott Champagne, F, Mercyhurst |
| 2004 | Holy Cross | Greg Kealey, F, Holy Cross |
| 2003 | Mercyhurst | David Wrigley, F, Mercyhurst |
| 2002 | Quinnipiac | Matt Craig, F, Quinnipiac |
| 2001 | Mercyhurst | Jeff Gould, F, Mercyhurst |
| 2000 | Connecticut | Mark Senerchia, G, Connecticut |
| 1999 | Holy Cross | Mike Maguire, D, Holy Cross |
| *-League was known as the MAAC prior to 2004. First year of Autobid was 2001. |
| *-recipient did not play on winning team. |
Tournament Results
Friday, March 8, 2013
Robert Morris 4, Sacred Heart 1
RIT 2, American Int'l 1
Canisius 4, Bentley 0
Mercyhurst 3, Army 1
Saturday, March 9, 2013
Robert Morris 6, Sacred Heart 1
RIT 7, American Int'l 1
Canisius 2, Bentley 1
Mercyhurst 5, Army 2
Friday, March 15, 2013
Connecticut 4, Robert Morris 1
Mercyhurst 3, Holy Cross 2
Canisius 4, Air Force 3
Niagara 3, RIT 2
Saturday, March 16, 2013
Holy Cross 3, Mercyhurst 2
Canisius 4, Air Force 3 (1 ot)
Niagara 2, RIT 1 (1 ot)
Connecticut 4, Robert Morris 3
Sunday, March 17, 2013
Mercyhurst 1, Holy Cross 0
Friday, March 22, 2013
Canisius 5, Niagara 3
Mercyhurst 4, Connecticut 1
Saturday, March 23, 2013
Canisius 7, Mercyhurst 2