Matchup
| Season | Visitor | Home | Winner | ||
| 2012-2013 | |||||
| 02/08/2013 | Princeton | 4 | Colgate | 2 | Princeton |
| 11/10/2012 | Colgate | 0 | Princeton | 4 | Princeton |
| 2011-2012 | |||||
| 01/13/2012 | Colgate | 2 | Princeton | 6 | Princeton |
| 11/19/2011 | Princeton | 1 | Colgate | 4 | Colgate |
| 2010-2011 | |||||
| 01/09/2011 | Colgate | 4 | Princeton | 5 | Princeton |
| 11/12/2010 | Princeton | 4 | Colgate | 3 | Princeton |
| 2009-2010 | |||||
| 02/05/2010 | Colgate | 3 | Princeton | 1 | Colgate |
| 11/21/2009 | Princeton | 4 | Colgate | 5 (ot) | Colgate |
| 2008-2009 | |||||
| 02/06/2009 | Princeton | 3 | Colgate | 2 (ot) | Princeton |
| 11/08/2008 | Colgate | 1 | Princeton | 2 (ot) | Princeton |
| 2007-2008 | |||||
| 03/21/2008 | Colgate | 0 | Princeton | 3 | Princeton |
| 02/22/2008 | Colgate | 2 | Princeton | 7 | Princeton |
| 11/03/2007 | Princeton | 2 | Colgate | 0 | Princeton |
| 2006-2007 | |||||
| 02/16/2007 | Princeton | 2 | Colgate | 1 | Princeton |
| 11/18/2006 | Colgate | 4 | Princeton | 2 | Colgate |
| 2005-2006 | |||||
| 01/13/2006 | Colgate | 3 | Princeton | 5 | Princeton |
| 12/03/2005 | Princeton | 2 | Colgate | 3 | Colgate |
| 2004-2005 | |||||
| 02/12/2005 | Colgate | 3 | Princeton | 1 | Colgate |
| 12/03/2004 | Princeton | 2 | Colgate | 4 | Colgate |
| 2003-2004 | |||||
| 02/14/2004 | Princeton | 2 | Colgate | 4 | Colgate |
| 11/07/2003 | Colgate | 3 | Princeton | 2 (ot) | Colgate |
| 2002-2003 | |||||
| 03/01/2003 | Colgate | 2 | Princeton | 2 (ot) | Tie |
| 11/08/2002 | Princeton | 3 | Colgate | 4 | Colgate |